Why FASD Diagnostic Criteria Matter

Blue-toned illustration of a child in profile with the brain visible, from the October 2026 NEAFAN newsletter.

A fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD) assessment can help people and families better understand strengths, challenges and support needs. It can also inform decisions about services and accommodations. But what happens when two diagnostic systems evaluate the same information differently?

What the researchers examined

A systematic review published in 2025 explored how often different FASD diagnostic criteria agree. Led by Graysen Myers and colleagues, the review identified six studies comparing eight diagnostic systems across 17 pairings. The researchers examined whether different sets of criteria reached the same FASD or no-FASD classification.

For individual children in the included comparisons, the reported agreement ranged from approximately 54% to 91%. That is a wide range for approaches intended to identify the same condition. It shows that the outcome can sometimes differ depending on which diagnostic framework is used.

Why can the results differ?

FASD assessment is complex. Diagnostic systems may place different weight on physical characteristics, neurodevelopmental functioning, information about prenatal alcohol exposure and other clinical evidence. Systems have also evolved over time and may define the thresholds for a diagnosis differently. These variations can contribute to disagreements, even when the same individual is being assessed.

The review does not mean that FASD diagnoses are unreliable or that one set of criteria has been proven superior. Rather, it highlights the need to understand the framework being applied and the evidence supporting the assessment. A diagnostic label is only one part of a wider clinical understanding of a person’s needs.

Why consistency matters to families

Different diagnostic outcomes can create uncertainty and frustration. Families may need an explanation of what was assessed, how the decision was reached and what supports are recommended. Where programs use diagnosis as an eligibility requirement, differences in criteria may also affect access to services. For researchers, inconsistent definitions make it harder to compare studies and interpret findings.

Looking ahead

The authors call for larger, multicentre research to understand why diagnostic results vary and how agreement could be improved. In the meantime, clear communication and comprehensive assessment remain important. Professionals can help by explaining findings in accessible language and keeping the person’s functioning, strengths and support needs at the centre of the discussion.

An assessment should also lead to a useful conversation about what happens next. Families may benefit from understanding the recommendations even when diagnostic terminology is complex. A clear explanation of functioning and support needs can guide practical decisions at home, in school and when working with service providers.

To learn more about FASD assessment and supports in northeast Alberta, visit NEAFAN.ca.

Research Source
Myers, G., Burd, M., Klug, M. G., Popova, S., & Burd, L. (2025). Comparing rates of agreement between different diagnostic criteria for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder: A systematic review. Alcohol, Clinical and Experimental Research, 49(1), 81–91.
https://doi.org/10.1111/acer.15492